If you’re looking for a sane and reasoned comparison of Media Composer 6 and Final Cut X — from the real world of the editing room trenches — look no further than the latest edition of Kanen Flowers’ “That Post Show” podcast. I was a participant, along with Scott Simmons, Paul del Vecchio and Kanen. The show is available from the iTunes store, or you can download it on the show notes page. This episode is facetiously titled “Edit Pro Supergood.” Fair warning: it’s long, and Skype failed us a few times, but it’s consistently substantive and, from my biased perspective, makes for interesting listening.
Final Cut X vs. Media Composer 6 Podcast
Posted December 27, 2011 by SteveCategories: Avid, Avid vs. Final Cut, Final Cut, Podcast
Intuit Relents — Sort Of
Posted December 22, 2011 by SteveCategories: Workflow
If you are one of the many people who have been unhappily looking at the end of Quicken on Lion, Intuit’s Aaron Forth, General Manager of their Personal Finance Group, offered you some hope today. The company is working to make Quicken 2007 compatible with Lion, with an expected release date of “early Spring.” How they are planning to do this has been left intentionally vague. I’ve spent some quality time over the last couple of months comparing Quicken Mac, Quicken PC under emulation, and MoneyDance, and I was reluctantly ready to move to the PC version. (I’ve been running it under Crossover, which is unique in that it doesn’t require Windows, but it’s quirky and not for everybody). Now, if you can wait till Spring, you may not have to switch. For details, check out Quicken’s Lion FAQ.
Avid Releases MC6
Posted November 16, 2011 by SteveCategories: Avid
Avid began distributing Media Composer 6 today. The new version has been upgraded to offer 64-bit support, and includes many new features, including a complete reinvention of the application’s approach to 3D-Stereo editing, the ability to mix in 5.1 and 7.1, “Open I/O” which allows you to use a variety of third party hardware options, tabbed bins, and a “reskinning” of the user interface. If you purchased version 5.5 in the last month or so, the upgrade is free, otherwise, it’s $300. Pricing for new licenses remains the same as with previous versions, and Avid has instituted a permanent “cross-grade” from FCP7 for $1500.
This version represents a bigger break from the past than previous upgrades. The new UI looks a lot like Premiere, and depending on your taste, you’re either going to love it or hate it. As with Version 5 and 5.5, it offers a brightness slider, but the lighter settings, which I suspect will be a lot easier to look at over the course of a long day, are flatter and less dimensional than in the past, making icons and buttons harder to see. Some icons have been changed, too, notably Mark In and Mark Out, and some terminology has been altered (Locators are now called Markers).
64-bit is important, but for the moment, it only permits the application to address more RAM. There’s no background rendering or saving or timeline manipulation, or any of the other exciting things that you may associate with the concept — that’s all been left for the future. The application seems stable, but keep in mind that everything has been recompiled, and your mileage may vary. (The Title Tool is one of the few exceptions — as a result, it now runs as a separate application.) 64-bit also means that older computers won’t work. If your Mac is more than about 3 years old you’re probably out of luck. (Go to System Profiler, click on “Software” and look for “64-bit Kernel and Extensions: Yes.” [Update: this may not be strictly necessary. See my Dec 1 comment.]) On the Mac, this version is officially supported only on OS X Lion, but it should run on Snow Leopard if you’re not using shared storage. You’ll also have to upgrade all of your AVX plug-ins.
Avid’s goal was reinvent 3D-Stereo editing and they seem to have done it in spades, with tools that are unmatched in any other offline editing application. There’s also support for a new 444 DNX format, which opens the door to high-quality conforms, though raster size is still limited to HD. 5.1 and 7.1 mixing are welcome, but their utility is limited because the playable track count is still stuck at 16. You’ll max things out with just three 5.1 stems (18 tracks).
Avid seems to be aiming this release at least partly at those who’ve been left high and dry by Apple, and support for many common third-party I/O cards will be welcomed by anybody making the switch. There’s also support for Avid’s “Artist Color,” three-ball controller. Symphony is now available in a software-only configuration for those using 3rd party hardware.
AMA has been expanded to include support for AVCHD and Red Epic, along with improvements to Quicktime and Pro Res, and AMA clips no longer display with yellow highlighting. There’s also an online purchasing option, something the company has dubbed “Avid Marketplace,” which allows you to purchase stock footage and plug-ins from within the application, and, yes, download your purchases in the background.
For more about MC6, see Avid’s Features List or this Creative Cow Article. You’ll find complete details in the What’s New pdf. Specific purchase and upgrade links can be found on this forum post from Avid’s Marianna Montague.
In other news, and for those of you who may have missed it, Avid laid off about 200 people a couple of weeks ago, or roughly 10% of its workforce. (Its quarterly report indicated roughly flat income compared to the same period last year, and a small loss of about $8 million.) One of those to go was Michael Phillips, an old friend, who had been at Avid since the beginning. He was a tireless advocate for the needs of longform editors, working with us personally and at countless seminars, and influencing the work of the entire community. Glenn Lea, the principle engineer responsible for FilmScribe, has also departed. I wish them success in whatever they do.
And on a personal note, many thanks to those of you who have been wondering why I haven’t been posting lately. I’ve been traveling. But I’m back now and I intend to get up to speed over the next few days. Stay tuned.
IATSE Health Plan
Posted November 15, 2011 by SteveCategories: Labor, Media and Society
Preparing for upcoming contract negotiations, the IATSE has been reaching out to the membership for feedback about our health plan. I went to a town hall meeting near LAX last night hosted by IA President Matt Loeb and VP Mike Miller, and I have to say that it was one of the best large-group IA meetings I’ve ever been to. The attitude, openness and intelligence of the leadership was terrific, and I was proud to be a member of this organization.
Our current contract expires at the end of July, and the chief challenge is going to be the medical plan. For details, we heard presentations by John Garner and David Wescoe, who articulately laid out some of the issues. By many measures we have one of the best plans in the nation, with lots of options, high quality care, and low out-of-pocket costs. But the plan is projected to need a lot of money over the next three years. Solving that problem will undoubtedly be contentious, and members would be well advised to learn as much as they can about it. There will be another meeting tonight in Burbank. You can also watch videos from previous meetings on the IA website.
Editors Lounge Friday
Posted October 27, 2011 by SteveCategories: Avid, Media and Society
Alphadogs’ monthly Editors Lounge is always an entertaining and informative event for editors of all stripes. The discussion tomorrow night will skip the usual tech talk and instead focus on how editors edit — the choices we make and why. With high-profile panelists from features, television, reality, and music videos, I suspect the discussion will reveal how similar we are, regardless of the material we cut.
The panel includes Mark Goldblatt, Andrew Seklir, Derek McCants and Bee Ottinger, and will be moderated by Debra Kaufman.
Details are here. Be sure to RSVP. Note that the event is being held at a new location. Doors open at 6:15, the panel starts at 7.
Steve
Posted October 6, 2011 by SteveCategories: Apple, Media and Society
By now, you all know that Steve Jobs passed away yesterday. Many words have been and will be written about him, and how much his vision and passion changed our lives. He was determined to see the future and make it real, and he did that many times over in his short career. Apple’s “think different” ad lauded “the crazy ones,” “the trouble makers,” “the ones who see things differently,” and “who push the human race forward.” Steve Jobs was very much one of those people, and today, one day into a new world without him, I wonder if any of us yet know how much he will be missed.
Recent Comments